Professor
The Professor project is hosted on HepForge. link
The following plots compare the tuning obtained with Professor to standard tunings.
Tune A was done by Rick Field and has been the standard tuning for Underlying Event
studies (most important background) for several years. The ATLAS tuning was done by
A. Moraeaes and is considered to be one of the standard tunings used in the ATLAS experiment.
CDF: Z-Boson p_T distribution
here we are very sensitive to gluon emissions prior to the hard 2->2 scattering since
initial state radiation of a gluon is more or less the only chance for the Z-Boson to gain
a p_T different from zero.
It is quite obvious that this observable was not looked at while doing tune A.
CDF: Average Lepton Pair p_T vs. Charged Multiplicity
This is a measurement from TEVATRON Run 2 @ 1960 GeV where one is interested in the average p_T of the lepton pair
from reconstructed Drell-Yan events (qqbar --> Z0 --> llbar) as a function of the overall charged multiplicity.
The ATLAS tuning dramatically overshoots the data, tune A produces too few soft events, while the systematic tuning (Professor) is dead on.